Raising the Minimum Wage is only the Beginning…

If you want to tackle poverty; but first lets discuss what raising the minimum wage would do. Low income workers spend the majority of their income, in fact judging by the statistic by the Federal Reserve Board Survey of Consumer finances in 2014 the bottom half of American families owned 0.8% of all financial assets which means they spend almost all of their income.

For those that are making the minimum wage this figure is worse. But this shouldn’t actually surprise anyone. It is foolish to believe that it is possible for a single full time minimum wage worker to save any sum of money. Not to mention support a family. At $7.25 an hour, 40 hours a week with not a single vacation over the course of one year the pretax income for that citizen is $15,080. Take away payroll taxes, state and federal income taxes and you are looking at a very low income and a very low savings rate which means very little wealth and not much discretionary income.

So what would a raise of the minimum wage to $15 an hour do? We know that because most minimum wage and low salary jobs are centered in the service sector they cannot be outsourced, unless you really think you need to fly to Vietnam every couple of weeks for a haircut and a Big Mac. Some Firms that are inefficient and have low productivity may close down, but since low income workers spend most of their incomes- and capitalism runs on sales not tax breaks- for most small businesses this would be mitigated by the fact that their customers now have more money to spend. Considering the unused capacity of the US economy it is more likely that higher wages would improve the balance sheets of small businesses, as citizens regain the ability to buy their goods and services.

In an interview with the Real News Network Dr. James K. Galbraith, the Lloyd M. Bentsen Jr. Chair in Government and Business at the University of Texas at Austin, said of raising the minimum wage to just $12 an hour, “one of the effects a higher minimum wage is that people do not quit their existing jobs so easily. They hang on to them. They’re more valuable… and so firms save training costs and transition costs that they would otherwise incur.”

The fact of the matter is that if you pay someone a decent wage he or she will see the work they do as valuable to society and will find dignity in their labor. If you pay them shit they will want to leave.

In his book The End of Normal, Dr. Galbraith also shows that the paltry minimum wage forces many Americans to rely on the Earned Income Tax Credit “thus the federal government effectively subsidizes predatory labor practices, especially in the American South.” It also creates tensions between white and Hispanic citizens as “employers find it advantageous to recruit low-skilled immigrants, often illegally, to fill low-wage jobs that Americans are unwilling to take.”

Looking at the NELP calculations from current population survey between 2012-2014 42.4% of all workers in the United States made less than $15 an hour; 36% of white workers, 48% of female works, 54.1% of African American workers and 59.5% of Hispanic workers made less than $15 an hour. Raising the minimum wage is a matter of justice for these people. But it will also equalize the pay rates at the lower end of the spectrum increasing the equality of pay between men and women, especially in the care services sector where the workers are lowly paid and disproportionately female.

More able to survive on one job rather than several, working families will be able to participate in their communities, in politics, cultural events and they will be able to reconstitute the political power they gained through middle and working class political organizations in the 1930’s and 40’s. This is evermore prescient when it comes to unionization since, going back to The End of Normal, “the premium accruing to union membership would be less; employers would therefore also have less of an incentive to resist unions,” as would workers who have been brainwashed into despising these working class organizations over the last four decades.

Concerning family life we have seen that coupled with the deterioration in minimum wages, which peaked in 1970, a steady increase in anxiety within households that can no longer rely on one breadwinner. In order to survive spouses and children across this country are being forced to enter the labor market when they would rather focus on homework or raising young children. And as we learned from the central thesis of Elizabeth Warren’s book The Two Income Trap, it also places them in a more precarious position if one of the family members loses their jobs, gets sick, or is injured at work since there is no one left to replace the lost earnings.

The balance sheets of individual states and of the Social Security trust fund would benefit as more wages means more tax revenue all levels of deficits would be reduced. Also households which are deleveraging will be able to do so with less impact on their ability to spend into the economy, which is extremely important since capitalism runs on sales.

Note: when it comes to the federal deficit and the affordability of programs such as Social Security there is no actual crisis as will be explained in an upcoming series on Modern Monetary theory. For more information check out this link of Stephanie Kelton who was appointed by Bernie Sanders as the Chief Economist for the Democratic minority staff on the Senate Budget Committee and of Warren Mosler to understand how a modern sovereign currency functions.

With stronger Unions, communities and families what should the fight be after raising the minimum wage, specifically in the fight against poverty? We will have to turn to the eradication of unemployment. This means a Job Guarantee program, also known as an Employer of Last Resort or ELR, where the government is willing to provide a job to anyone who is able and willing to work.

Hyman Minsky showed in 1974, and Stephanie Kelton with L. Randal Wray showed again in 2000 that by providing one minimum wage job to anyone able and willing to work we could reduce poverty by two thirds! In 2000 the minimum wage was $5.15, adjusted for inflation this is about $7.14 today. A real world case study of a program similar to an ELR was done by L. Randall Wray and Pavlina Tchernova on the Jefes de Hogar Program implemented in Argentina to employ the heads of households during their depression in the early 2000’s. Though not a true ELR “after only 4 months after implementation of Jefes in April 2002, the indigence rates among participating households had fallen by nearly 25% and among individuals by over 18%.” Between May 2002 and May 2003 unemployment had fallen by almost 50%, from 21.5% to 15.6%. Also the minimum wage paid by the ELR program effectively becomes the national minimum wage. Because implementation of Job guarantee discards the need for unemployment insurance, poverty programs, and ineffective job training programs the cost would be around 1% of GDP, with the net cost being closer to zero. A study has yet to be done on what the impact would be of providing a job to anyone able and willing to work at $15 an hour but at more than twice the current Federal minimum wage of $7.25 one can be sure that we would be a far healthier society.

So as labor wakes up from its long dormancy the first step is to raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour. But if we want to win the war on poverty we must turn next to eradicate unemployment altogether.

By David Leo Glotzer

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Raising the Minimum Wage is only the Beginning…

  1. I understand most of the logic and passion of raising the minimum wage, but as a business owner I’ve watched as 40% of my employees are habitually late for work, and 60% fail to undertake a minimum level of initiative, and our starting pay is $10 per hour. Maybe rural America is in a different place, but I think we are dramatically underestimating the number of people whose primary goal is to get paid to do as little as possible.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I also think that this is a problem but I believe that it is a cultural phenomenon. I am currently on exchange in the Netherlands where service workers have a much higher income and I don’t see the same cynicism towards work at the lower end of the wage scale. I think that it has to do with the dignity that comes with being able support yourself or your family through your labor. This is a psychological phenomena which I don’t think will be resolved without at least a decade of undoing the misanthropic view we have of lower paid employees. We did it in the 1930’s under Roosevelt I am optimistic that with the proper political (not through electoral politics but through civil society, as was done in the 30’s) we can do it again.

      Liked by 2 people

    • I am a supporter of many socialist and progressive policies, a fan of modern monetary theory, and a former libertarian(still a little bit I suppose).

      I am a huge critic of the minimum wage. I see it as an enforced productivity quota. I see it as political laziness to mandate that private businesses supply a certain amount of benefits but not supply those benefits directly.

      Personally, I am a pretty frugal person, and am not motivated to work even part time at minimum wage. It’s just far too much work and too much money for my tastes(low wage jobs are usually hard work). I think there should be no federal or state minimum wages and modest minimum wages for cities/counties only are tolerable(though still not the ideal policy). Then we wouldn’t have to outsource so much and people could live in affordable communities and we wouldn’t need our ridiculously racist immigration policies.

      The whole minimum wage thing is like boiling the proverbial frog. We slowly raise it, and it’s hard to measure the negative effects. The companies that remain can afford it, but only by being large advertising driven franchises, niche premium services, reducing their workforce, or demanding more from workers. It doesn’t have immediate effects on employment numbers, and the economic research is complex, conflicted, inconclusive and inadequate.

      What if I told you that minimum wage could reduce your work options and quality of work without affecting employment numbers? I don’t think studies are always looking at the right things.

      You can read many more similar rants of mine at fixpublicpolicy.wordpress.com or on my twitter: @fixpublicpolicy

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Over the years I have watched the minimum wage grow, but so has the overall cost of living. If we raise the minimum wage to over double what it is now, what is going to happen to the cost of everything else? What is going to happen to the small businesses? I too live in a rural community and work for a family-owned business and have to supplement my income with other side jobs. I have a Master’s Degree and still make less than $15 per hour. I do agree minimum wage should be increased, but gradually as it has been done over the years. This country cannot afford to bankrupt every small business out there, which is what will happen. We will then all be thrown into new tax brackets and the government will take more and more. With the cost of living wage increases, so increases the overall cost of living. I really wish people would look at the overall impact this will have: small business, taxes, insurance, groceries, fuel, utilities, etc…

    Like

  3. Pingback: Raising The Minimum Wage Is Only The Beginning…—The Déclassé Intellectual - Rationally Thinking Out Loud

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s